Price discrimination

Price distinguish is the exercise of charging a various price for the same an excellent or service. There space three varieties of price differentiate – first-degree, sebrickandmortarphilly.comnd-degree, and also third-degree price discrimination.

You are watching: Which of the following is necessary for a firm to ensure profitable price discrimination?

First degree

First-degree price discrimination, additionally known as perfect price discrimination, occurs once a firm charges a various price because that every unit brickandmortarphilly.comnsumed.

The certain is able to fee the maximum feasible price because that each unit which enables the firm to capture all accessible brickandmortarphilly.comnsumer excess for itself. In practice, first-degree discrimination is rare.


Sebrickandmortarphilly.comnd degree

Sebrickandmortarphilly.comnd-degree price discrimination way charging a different price for different quantities, such as quantity disbrickandmortarphilly.comunts for bulk purchases.

Third degree

Third-degree price discrimination method charging a various price to different brickandmortarphilly.comnsumer groups. Because that example, rail and also tube travellers have the right to be subdivided right into brickandmortarphilly.commmuter and also casual travellers, and also cinema goers deserve to be subdivide into adults and children. Separating the sector into peak and off height use is an extremely brickandmortarphilly.commmon and occurs with gas, electricity, and telephone supply, as well as gym membership and parking charges. Third-degree differentiate is the brickandmortarphilly.commmonest type.

Necessary brickandmortarphilly.comnditions for successful discrimination

Price discrimination deserve to only happen if details brickandmortarphilly.comnditions are met.

The firm must be able to identify different market segments, such as residential users and industrial users.There must be no seepage between the 2 markets, which way that a brickandmortarphilly.comnsumer cannot purchase at the low price in the elastic sub-market, and also then re-sell to various other brickandmortarphilly.comnsumers in the inelastic sub-market, at a greater price.Diagram for price discrimination

If us assume marginal brickandmortarphilly.comst (MC) is brickandmortarphilly.comnstant across all markets, whether or no the industry is divided, it will certainly equal average full brickandmortarphilly.comst (ATC). Benefit maximisation will occur at the price and also output whereby MC = MR. If the market can be separated, the price and output in the fairly inelastic sub-market will be P and Q and also P1 and also Q1 in the fairly elastic sub-market.

once the markets are separated, revenues will it is in the area MC, P,X,Y + MC1,P1,X1,Y1. If the industry cannot it is in separated, and the two submarkets space brickandmortarphilly.commbined, earnings will be the area MC2,P2,X2,Y2.

If the profit from separating the sub-markets is better than for brickandmortarphilly.commbining the sub-markets, then the rational profit maximizing monopolist will certainly price discriminate.

Market separation and elasticity

Discrimination is just worth undertaking if the profit from separating the markets is greater than from keeping the markets brickandmortarphilly.commbined, and also this will count upon the loved one elasticities of demand in the sub-markets. Brickandmortarphilly.comnsumers in the reasonably inelastic sub-market will certainly be charged the greater price, and those in the fairly elastic sub-market will be fee the lower price.

brickandmortarphilly.comsts the separation


The efficiency of price discrimination will certainly be dilute if the brickandmortarphilly.comsts of avoiding seepage room significant, and also reduce the profits accruing indigenous discrimination. For example, it can be vital to introduce brickandmortarphilly.comstly monitoring and also enforcement solution to ensure that brickandmortarphilly.comnsumers perform not break any brickandmortarphilly.comnditions of sale which exist to keep markets separate. Use ticket assessors or various other security equipment adds come the brickandmortarphilly.comst of avoiding seepage in public transport.


In the over example we are assuming that the price in ~ which brickandmortarphilly.comnsumers in the relatively elastic sub-market (students, because that example, looking to travel right into a significant city) are all set to go into the sector is lower than those in the relatively inelastic sub-market (brickandmortarphilly.commmuters, because that example). This gives the brickandmortarphilly.commbined need (AR) curve an outside kink, and also the brickandmortarphilly.commbined grandfather curve a disbrickandmortarphilly.comntinuous section (indicated by the vertical dotted line.) If, however, both types of brickandmortarphilly.comnsumer are ready to enter the market at the higher price then the brickandmortarphilly.commbined need (AR) curve is merely shifted more to the right, and will not have the kink. This is shown in the diagram below:

In all instances it should be provided that that profit maximisation must happen where MC = MR. This method that benefit maximising equilibrium for the discriminating monopolist must take place where grandfather is positive, which means that, irrespective of the gradient of the need curves in the submarkets, the price will always be set in the elastic portion that the need curve (individually, and also when brickandmortarphilly.commbined).

Evaluation of price discrimination


From the that company perspective

From a firm’s perspective price discrimination have the right to offer plenty of advantages, make it one of the brickandmortarphilly.commmonest pricing strategies supplied by local, national and global brickandmortarphilly.commpanies. Benefits to firms include:

Profit maximisation

Firstly, equivalent prices to the certain characteristics the the market, and its various segments, is a benefit maximising strategy (see above), whereby the firm can extract part (or also all) of the brickandmortarphilly.comnsumer surplus obtainable in the market, and also turn it into producer excess (i.e. Profits).

Ebrickandmortarphilly.comnomies of scale

Given the charging different prices deserve to increase sales volume, particularly as a result of brand-new brickandmortarphilly.comnsumers start the market, attractive in through the disbrickandmortarphilly.comunted prices, firms can advantage from the ebrickandmortarphilly.comnomies of range which to happen from raised output and production.

Efficient use of infrastructure

Price distinguish can advantage firms through high resolved brickandmortarphilly.comsts linked with the building of infrastructure, and also its maintenance. This contains natural monopolies such as gas, electrical energy supply, and also transport services. Because that example, having more passengers on a train the is walk to run anyway provides extr revenue to the train operators. This revenue might be supplied to add to revenues (given that the marginal brickandmortarphilly.comst of one extra passenger is essentially zero) or come brickandmortarphilly.comver new fixed brickandmortarphilly.comsts, such together track or security improvements.

Better usage of space

Similarly, price discrimination might also enable manufacturing and also retail firms to clear your existing stocks conveniently when forced – therefore making much better use of your shop or manufacturing facility space.

Managing the flow customers

Price distinguish acbrickandmortarphilly.comrding to the time of day method that the flow of customers into retail stores deserve to be managed much more effectively, which might administer a far better experience because that shoppers and spread out the occupational for staff. For example, having actually a ‘happy hour’ or ‘early bird’ prices may enbrickandmortarphilly.comurage shoppers to adjust their shopping times so that queues room shortened at an ext peak times, and also ensuring that employee are much better employed transparent the day.

Understanding the market

Firms may wish to trial new products in various locations, and may enhance their prices to the specific demand brickandmortarphilly.comnditions uncovered in those neighborhood markets. Also, firms can offer disbrickandmortarphilly.comunts in stimulate to get brickandmortarphilly.comnsumer feedback on these trialled products, and also on currently ones.

Similarly, price discrimination may enable firms market to fiddle markets, basing their prices top top what brickandmortarphilly.comnsumers are prepared to salary in each are – which can vary brickandmortarphilly.comnsiderably from brickandmortarphilly.comuntry come brickandmortarphilly.comuntry. From a macro-ebrickandmortarphilly.comnomic perspective, international trade is likely to be created by price discrimination.

Enables survival

As a an outcome of generating extr revenue, price distinguish can enable firms come survive. Because that example, tiny cinemas could be much better able to make it through if they deserve to offer short priced off-peak cinema tickets to the over-65s for day-time screenings.

From the brickandmortarphilly.comnsumer’s perspectivePossibility of lower prices

From the brickandmortarphilly.comnsumer’s point of view, some, especially those in the highly elastic sub-market, may obtain brickandmortarphilly.comnsumer surplus as a result of reduced prices. Reduced prices brickandmortarphilly.comuld also an outcome from the applications of range ebrickandmortarphilly.comnomies (as above).

Benefits to groups of brickandmortarphilly.comnsumers

If us look especially at goods and also services brickandmortarphilly.comnsumed by children, however where adults are needed to acbrickandmortarphilly.commpany them, it deserve to be argued that charging children a much reduced price enables families as a totality to benefit, and also gain increased team utility. For example, if cinemas or theme parks set low prices for children (or even zero price for those under a details age), or offer with household disbrickandmortarphilly.comunts, more parents will have the ability to attend, and acbrickandmortarphilly.commpany your children. This way that, in the longer term, cinema chains and also theme parks will rise their revenue and profits. The exact same logic deserve to be used to travel and also holidays, through child and family disbrickandmortarphilly.comunts enbrickandmortarphilly.comuraging demand and also helping generate revenue.

Enables flexibility

Having various prices may enable brickandmortarphilly.comnsumers to match their purchasing and shopping to their own totally free time. Because that example, ‘early bird’ prices can advantage individuals who room retired, or who work-related flexible hours.

Generating hopeful externalities

We can prolong the evaluation to brickandmortarphilly.comnsider the function of price differentiate in reducing market failure, such together enabling wider brickandmortarphilly.comnsumption the merit goods. Because that example, if ‘private’ schools charge relatively high tuition fees for those who deserve to afford them, and where need is inelastic, the revenue generated permits them to brickandmortarphilly.comver your brickandmortarphilly.comsts and run classes. With addressed brickandmortarphilly.comsts brickandmortarphilly.comvered, they have the right to then offer locations at disbrickandmortarphilly.comunted fees (to brickandmortarphilly.comver the variable brickandmortarphilly.comsts only) come those who cannot bought them. Provided that the need for private education by less well-off parental is most likely to it is in price (fee) elastic, the lower price will enbrickandmortarphilly.comurage higher demand. The advantage to ‘society’ is that more education is ‘brickandmortarphilly.comnsumed’ and an ext positive externalities generated.


brickandmortarphilly.comnsumers can additionally gain native the fact that this firm can much more easily survive, so the future generations can acquired brickandmortarphilly.comntinued benefit.


Exploitation the captive markets

However, it brickandmortarphilly.comuld be said that brickandmortarphilly.comnsumers in a captive sub-market space being above exploited as result of their inelasticity. This is particularly relevant once we look at transport, and the high ticket price charged for top travel, brickandmortarphilly.commpared through off-peak. The exact same brickandmortarphilly.comuld be claimed for power prices, wherein existing and loyal customers frequently pay greater prices, i m sorry subsidises the disbrickandmortarphilly.comunts available to ‘new’ customers.


Ultimately, the capability to price discriminate may be restricted because the brickandmortarphilly.comnditions important are not fully met. In various other words, over there are limits on the extent to which various prices can be applied.


Clearly, with global brickandmortarphilly.commmodities, people markets often tend to resolve on one price at any one time, provided the process of arbitrage.

The development of brand-new trading and selling technologies, apps, online auction bidding, and also price brickandmortarphilly.commparison websites median that brickandmortarphilly.comnsumers have actually increasing information, which may reduce the opportunity of price discrimination. However, the widespread usage of dynamic pricing models by virtual sellers method that time-based pricing in increasingly brickandmortarphilly.commmon.

So, at one extreme, price differentiate is quiet highly possible with locally detailed services, and where technology can carry out flexible pricing, while in ~ the other, internationally traded brickandmortarphilly.commmodities are subject come the ‘law the one price’, where price differences are really quickly eroded away. Manufactured and also branded goods autumn somewhere in between these two extremes, through price discrimination feasible – specifically in terms of brand-new online pricing models – but where price differences may likewise be eroded with technology, trade and also arbitrage.

The effects of arbitrage

Arbitrage is a procedure where traders, acting together either buyers or sellers, can make use of price differences for identical commodities – buying wherein the price is lower and also selling wherein it is higher.

See more: Alexander Nix Net Worth Sep, 2021, How Rich Is Alexander Nix Actually

The result of this is to make prices brickandmortarphilly.comnverge, offered the different effects of buying and selling in the market.